How to Lower Your Homeowners Insurance Premium Without Sacrificing Coverage

Homeowners insurance rates have been a hot topic across Michigan for several years. After a period of significant increases, we’re beginning to see signs of a more stable insurance marketplace.

That’s welcome news for Northern Michigan homeowners!

But whether your insurance premium is increasing, decreasing, or staying about the same, there’s still a question worth asking:

Am I getting the best value for my homeowners insurance?

The good news is that there are several ways to potentially lower your insurance premium without giving up the protection you’ve worked hard to put in place.

1. Make Sure You’re Receiving Every Available Discount

Insurance companies offer a surprising number of discounts, and they aren’t always identical from one company to another.

Depending on your insurance carrier, discounts may be available for:

  • Combining home and auto insurance
  • Having multiple policies with the same company
  • Maintaining a claim-free history
  • Installing monitored security or fire alarms
  • Having certain protective devices
  • Paying your premium in full
  • Using automatic payments or paperless billing
  • Qualifying for age-related or other company-specific discounts

Some discounts are applied automatically, while others may require updated information. I have seen far too many clients who have bundled their policies with the same company however the multi-policy discounts were never added. Make sure and check to see that you are receiving this important discount if you have more than one policy with the same company. Most declaration pages (the 2+ pages that discuss your specific coverages) have a discount ‘section’ that you can check.

The important thing is to ask your agent to review which discounts are available and whether you’re receiving them.

2. Consider Increasing Your Deductible

Your deductible is the amount you’re responsible for paying toward a covered loss before your insurance company pays the remaining eligible amount.

Generally, choosing a higher deductible can reduce your annual premium.

For example, moving from a $1,000 deductible to a $2,500 deductible may produce meaningful savings, depending on your insurance company.

But don’t make that change without considering the bigger picture.

If a storm damages your roof tomorrow, would you be comfortable paying $2,500 out of pocket?

A higher deductible can be a smart financial decision for homeowners who have adequate savings.

The goal is to find the right balance between premium savings and the amount of risk you’re comfortable retaining. An easy way I have clients make this decision is to look at how many years you would need to have no claims to make up for the higher deductible.

Example: Your savings is $250 a year to go from $1,000 to $2,500. That means you have to pay $1,500 more when you have a claim. You would need to go 6 years to make up that difference. However, many clients never have a home claim or only have 1 or 2 in their lifetime. The savings may be worthwhile as long as you can afford the higher deductible when it happens.

3. Review Your Home’s Information for Accuracy

Insurance companies use detailed information about your home to calculate premiums.

That may include:

  • Square footage
  • Year of construction
  • Roofing materials and age
  • Heating systems
  • Construction materials
  • Bathrooms and interior finishes
  • Renovations and improvements
  • Detached structures

If the information is incorrect, your insurance premium or coverage could be affected.

Perhaps your roof was replaced three years ago, but your insurance company still shows it as 20 years old. This can surprisingly be a large discount of more than $150 a year depending on the value of your home.

Or let’s say that your home’s construction details were entered incorrectly years ago. A review with your agent can be done fairly quickly and an accurate replacement-cost estimate is important for both proper protection and fair pricing.

However, reducing your dwelling coverage simply to lower your premium is not a good strategy.

Your insurance should reflect what it would realistically cost to rebuild your home after a covered loss. Keep in mind that this needs to ‘include’ the cost to tear down what is remaining of the structure. In my 38 year history, I have had very few that didn’t cost tens of thousands of dollars to have torn down and the property prepared for a rebuilding of the home.

4. Ask About Home Safety and Protective Devices

Some insurance companies offer discounts for devices that help prevent or reduce losses.

These may include:

  • Monitored burglar alarms
  • Central-station fire alarms
  • Automatic water shutoff systems
  • Water-leak detection systems
  • Other approved protective devices

For Northern Michigan homeowners, water detection can be especially valuable.

A leaking pipe or failed appliance can cause thousands of dollars in damage before anyone notices.

Not every insurance company offers a discount for every device, so check with your agent before purchasing expensive equipment solely for insurance savings.

Even when there isn’t a discount, preventing a major loss has financial value of its own.

5. Review Your Home and Auto Insurance Together

Bundling home and auto insurance with the same company can provide significant savings.

But here’s something many consumers don’t realize:

The company offering the largest bundling discount isn’t necessarily the company offering the lowest total premium.

One insurer might offer a substantial homeowners discount but charge more for auto insurance.

Another may provide a smaller discount while offering a better overall package.

That’s why comparing the combined cost of your insurance program is often more useful than looking at a single policy.

6. Don’t Overlook Changes in the Insurance Marketplace

Insurance companies regularly adjust their pricing, underwriting guidelines, and available discounts.

The company that offered the most competitive premium five years ago may not be the most competitive today.

And the company that wasn’t interested in insuring your home several years ago may now be a good option.

This is one of the advantages of working with an independent insurance agency.

However, I am always honest with clients that changing insurance companies every year isn’t necessarily the best strategy.

Coverage quality, claims service, financial stability, and long-term relationships matter too.

The objective should be the right coverage at a competitive price, not simply the lowest number.

7. Be Careful About Cutting Coverage to Save Money

This may be the most important point in the entire article.

Some of the easiest ways to lower an insurance premium can also create the most expensive problems after a claim.

For example:

  • Reducing your dwelling limit below an appropriate replacement-cost amount
  • Eliminating water-backup coverage
  • Reducing personal liability limits
  • Removing valuable endorsements
  • Accepting a less comprehensive policy form
  • Changing from replacement-cost protection to actual cash value coverage

Those changes may reduce your premium.

But they can also transfer significant financial risk back to you.

Saving $200 annually isn’t much of a bargain if it creates a $25,000 coverage gap after a loss.

8. Have Your Insurance Reviewed Periodically

Your home changes.

Your financial situation changes.

Insurance companies change.

And the insurance marketplace changes.

That makes periodic insurance reviews valuable, even when you haven’t experienced a large premium increase.

A review may uncover missed discounts, outdated property information, opportunities to adjust deductibles, or a different insurance company that better fits your needs.

It can also identify coverage gaps that deserve attention.

The Bottom Line

Lowering your homeowners insurance premium doesn’t have to mean sacrificing the protection you’ve worked hard to build.

Sometimes the savings come from a deductible adjustment.

Sometimes they’re hiding in discounts you didn’t know existed.

And sometimes a different insurance company simply offers a better combination of coverage and price.

At Cardinal Insurance Group, we help homeowners throughout Traverse City and Northern Michigan understand their options and make informed insurance decisions.

Call Email Claims Payments